
This year's nominees for the
Rock & Roll Hall of Fame were
announced yesterday. I happen to dig the concept of the Hall - I appreciate lifetime-achievement awards and the idea of musicians respecting their foremothers and forefathers - but I am frequently frustrated by the Hall's selection process.
And increasingly, I'm frustrated by the Hall's name. Noise has been made in recent years over the induction of artists who were not "rock & roll" by its standard definition: doo-wop, jazz, heavy metal, disco, and most recently hip-hop. And that's kind of silly. Despite its name, the Rock Hall's purpose extends to all of popular music, and it's needlessly rockist (and potentially racist) to deny an act as influential as Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five just because they weren't or didn't "rock." There's a sizable strain of music critics who harbor unfounded assumptions about popular music: that it should have a foundation of guitar, bass, and drums; that it should be written by the performer; that it should have a tough, pounding energy that especially comes through on tour. It's a needlessly narrow definition, and it has led to the induction of novelty acts like the Ramones and Sex Pistols in the absence of artists with larger bodies of successful work (like the Monkees, Donna Summer, and Three Dog Night) or broader influence (Chic, Afrika Bambaataa).
This year the Hall is finally giving finalist consideration to one of my personally championed bands: War, an eight-piece out of L.A. whose sound combined rock, funk, and Latin grooves in a reflection of their hometown melting pool. Few bands scored Top 10 hits in such a wide array of styles: the stoner jam of "Spill the Wine," the curious quacking funk of "Low Rider," the aggrieved desperation shout of "The World Is a Ghetto," the slamming tipsy grooves of "Cisco Kid" and "Gypsy Man," the mellow reverie of "Summer."
And a big favorite of mine, the joyous and often silly "Why Can't We Be Friends?" They went over the top with
this promo video (come on, a bro-hug with a Klansman?), and Lee Oskar'll never win any awards for his lyric-writing or delivery, but it is impossible to get through this round, where everyone gets a turn, without a smile crossing your face.
I hope you make it in, guys.